A Failed attempt at creating Guidelines for Visual GUI Testing [Elektronisk resurs] An industrial case study

• Software development is governed by guidelines that aim to improve the code's qualities, such as maintainability. However, whilst coding guidelines are commonplace for software, guidelines for testware are much less common. In particular, for GUI-based tests driven with image recognition, also referred to as Visual GUI Testing (VGT), explicit coding guidelines are missing.In this industrial case study, performed at the Swedish defence contractor Saab AB, we propose a set of coding guidelines for VGT and evaluate their impact on test scripts for an industrial, safety-critical system. To study the guidelines' effect on maintenance costs, five representative manual test cases are each translated with and without the proposed guidelines in the two VGT tools SikuliX and EyeAutomate. As such, 20 test scripts were developed, with a combined development cost of more than 100 man-hours. Three of the tests are then maintained by one researcher and two practitioners for another version of the system and costs measured to evaluate return on investment. This analysis is complemented with observations and interviews to elicit practitioners' perceptions and experiences with VGT.Results show that scripts developed with the guidelines had higher maintenance costs than scripts developed without guidelines. This is supported by qualitative results that many of the guidelines are considered inappropriate, superfluous or unnecessary due to the inherent properties of the scripts, e.g. their natural small size, linear flows, natural separation of concerns, and more. We conclude that there are differences between VGT scripts and software that prohibit direct translation of guidelines between the two. As such, we consider our study as a failure but argue that several lessons can be drawn from our results to guide future research into guidelines for VGT and GUI-based test automation. © 2021 IEEE. 

Ämnesord

Natural Sciences  (hsv)

Computer and Information Sciences  (hsv)

Software Engineering  (hsv)

Naturvetenskap  (hsv)

Data- och informationsvetenskap  (hsv)

Programvaruteknik  (hsv)

Genre

government publication  (marcgt)

Indexterm och SAB-rubrik

Automated Testing

Case study

Guidelines for testing

Industrial study

Visual GUI testing

Accident prevention

Cost benefit analysis

Costs

Graphical user interfaces

Image coding

Image recognition

Maintenance

Safety testing

Software design

Verification

Defence contractors

Development costs

Industrial case study

Maintenance cost

Safety critical systems

Separation of concerns

Test Automation

Software testing